[rescue] FTP site for archive of _all_ old platforms on it's way
slawmaster at gmail.com
Sat Jun 16 21:22:44 CDT 2007
On 6/16/07, Magnus <magnus at yonderway.com> wrote:
> John Floren wrote:
> > I think you guys may be overestimating the number of people who would
> > be seeding all these files.
> It doesn't take many. Every individual seeder helps to defray the
> bandwidth hit to the original seeder. Having a number of simultaneous
> leeches even helps, as the leeches leech off of each other at the same
> time that they are leeching off of the seeds.
> When a dataset is first announced, it's likely to have a bunch of
> leeches at once. They will all help shoulder the load. When interest
> trails off and only one or two at a time come, the hit to a seeder with
> no peers is going to be on-par with the hit an ftp server would take.
> > How many people do you think are out there
> > who really want a copy of <little-known PDP-11 OS> in the first place,
> > let alone are willing to torrent it and then leave the torrent running
> > for an indefinite length of time?
> Try grabbing the torrent for one of the oddball architecture betas of
> CentOS Linux sometime, that hasn't been touched in like a year or two
> and has been abandoned by the maintainers, and see how many seeds jump
> on. You will be surprised (I sure was).
> > FTP, at least, I can see that the file is there and available, and my
> > access to it isn't controlled by the number of other people who have
> > downloaded it.
> As long as the original party continues to have an interest in hosting
> the data, he can continue to seed it. Your access is unhindered. If
> he's lost interest in hosting it, the ftp site would be just as likely
> to go away.
I guess there is a point I didn't consider--if Ethan has his server
seeding all the files, then yeah, they'll always be available, and at
worst his bandwidth usage will match that of a straight FTP server.
I'm too used to getting a torrent and finding 0 seeders and 2
leechers... ah well.
Good luck, Ethan!
Ph'nglui mglw'nafh Cthulhu R'lyeh wgah'nagl fhtagn
More information about the rescue